Ampersands: Notes and Everything Between
Jonathan Valania
i don't remember deciding to become a writer.
i remember becoming overwhelmed.
there were too many thoughts. too many emotions. too many questions arriving all at once. every answer seemed to split into two more questions before i had finished asking the first. my mind rarely moved in straight lines. one memory called another. one feeling interrupted the next. joy arrived carrying grief. hope walked beside fear. certainty never lasted long without doubt finding a chair beside it.
for a long time i thought something was wrong with me. i assumed everyone else had learned how to separate things that refused to separate inside my own mind. they seemed able to arrive at conclusions. i kept arriving at more questions. i spent years trying to untangle thoughts that seemed determined to stay together.
writing became the first place i didn't have to.
the page never asked my thoughts to arrive in order. it never demanded that contradictions resolve themselves before i was allowed to continue. it let grief sit beside gratitude. faith beside doubt. love beside anger. memory beside forgetting. i could leave every unfinished question exactly where i found it, and somehow the page still held together.
i didn't know it then, but i had already started thinking in ampersands. it would take years before i understood that this wasn't only how i wrote. it was how i understood the world.
i kept trying to separate things that life refused to divide. i wanted grief without gratitude. faith without doubt. love without loss. certainty without questions. i thought healing meant becoming one consistent version of myself, someone who no longer contradicted his own thoughts.
life had other plans.
the older i became, the less interested i was in choosing between opposing truths. i stopped asking whether the world was beautiful or cruel. it had always been both. i stopped asking whether people were broken or good. they had always been both. i stopped asking whether i was the child i had been, the father i was becoming, or the man still trying to understand himself.
i was all of them.
this book grew out of that realization.
the poems and essays that follow were never meant to become a collection. they were written years apart, often without any awareness that they belonged together. only when i laid them beside one another did i realize they had been asking the same questions from different directions.
they were what i wrote when i searched for answers.
i didn't find many. instead, i found better questions.
questions have a way of changing shape over time. when i was younger, i wanted to know why. why people leave. why love changes. why grief lingers. why god sometimes feels silent. why memory preserves ordinary afternoons while entire years quietly disappear. i thought if i looked hard enough, i would eventually arrive at an answer capable of quieting everything else.
every supposed answer simply widened the question.
for a while, that frustrated me. i mistook uncertainty for failure. i thought understanding meant reaching a conclusion and staying there. i admired people who sounded certain. they seemed lighter somehow. steadier. as though they had finally solved whatever puzzle i was still struggling to assemble.
the older i became, the more suspicious i grew of certainty.
certainty closes doors. wonder leaves them open.
i don't think this book is about finding answers anymore. i think it's about paying attention.
paying attention to the ordinary moments that quietly become extraordinary. paying attention to the people who continue speaking inside us long after they've gone. paying attention to the ways grief changes shape instead of disappearing. paying attention to the contradictions we spend so much of our lives trying to untangle, only to discover they were never knots in the first place.
that's all writing has ever been for me.
not an attempt to explain the world.
an attempt to notice it.
if these pages have anything to offer, i hope it isn't certainty. i hope they offer permission. permission to ask another question. permission to change your mind. permission to hold two truths beside one another without demanding that either one disappear.
because somewhere between certainty & confusion...
between memory & forgetting...
between grief & gratitude...
between who we've been & who we're becoming...
i've found something that feels remarkably like peace.
i hope, somewhere in these pages,
you find a little of your own.